Skip to content
World events. A considered read.
5 min read

Tehran weighs Vance's exit from Iran talks as Hormuz attacks continue

Iranian analysts say moving JD Vance off the Iran file could raise the risk of conflict, while UK maritime monitors logged eight new incidents in the Strait of Hormuz.

Newsroom
An officer seen from behind watches a merchant ship through bridge windows, with binoculars and navigation equipment nearby and rocky headlands bordering the water.

Decision-makers in Tehran are considering the implications of Vice President JD Vance’s removal from the Iran file so he can focus on domestic issues. Analysts say the shift could increase the chances of conflict. Vance had been the US chief negotiator. President Donald Trump said on Thursday, in a post on Truth Social, that Vance should concentrate on alleged Democratic corruption and that a deal with Iran was no longer a government priority. Tehran is believed to have viewed Vance as one of the more pragmatic figures in the administration since the United States and Israel launched a surprise war on Iran on 28 February.

Nasser Hadian, professor of international relations at the University of Tehran, said assigning Vance to the alleged domestic corruption case mainly signalled a confrontation with the Democrats after their sweeping midterm victories against the governing Republican Party. He said the move may also serve Israel, which is reportedly eager for Trump to launch new strikes after Vance blamed the Republicans’ humiliating midterm defeat on the war. Hadian said another signal to Iran was that reaching a deal is not a priority and that the person known for a relatively softer stance had been redirected.

Vance is believed to have favoured a negotiated end to the war because of its rising economic costs for US citizens and opposition suggested in opinion polls. He was backed by envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff when he negotiated a memorandum of understanding with Iran in June. That understanding, now defunct, briefly paused the war and resumed shipping in the Strait of Hormuz. Rubio has called Iranian authorities “insane” for their demands on ending the war, while also acknowledging the cost of an all-out war and seeking to prevail through deeper economic pressure and isolation of all Iranians. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, who has faced an impeachment vote over his role in the war, and Central Command chief Brad Cooper are reportedly in favour of renewed military action.

Vance wrote to Iran’s security chief, Mohsen Rezaei, in late October as regional mediators renewed efforts to narrow the gaps. Rezaei initially described the tone as positive. By last week he was calling claims of progress and a possible direct meeting with Vance “fake news about imaginary talks”. On X he wrote: “You lost the war and the election. Vance has conceded, Rubio is heading for the exit, Hegseth is about to be fired, and the CENTCOM commander is now a podcaster!”

Mediated contacts are continuing, and no breakthrough is expected. Tehran is demanding seven conditions and a clear sequence of concessions, terms that appear unacceptable to the United States. Mohammad Saleh Sedghian, director of the Arab Center for Iranian Studies, said Trump has repeatedly highlighted alleged rifts within the Iranian negotiating team, while Iranian authorities are also questioning whether Washington would stand by another agreement. He asked what guarantee there would be that Trump would enforce a deal even if Rezaei and Vance reached one. Sedghian said mistrust is complicating the prospects, so the US siege and harsh sanctions will continue, and the blockade and disruptions are significantly raising costs for Iranian people. He described the present state, with neither open war nor a negotiated resolution, as very dangerous, and said it could cost Iran more than a relatively shorter military conflict with Washington.

Reformist newspaper Shargh argued this week that Vance’s role on Iran is unresolved rather than definitely ended, and that the conflict could escalate further. Conservative daily Farhikhtegan disputed the portrayal of Vance as genuinely anti-war, arguing that diplomacy, military force and economic pressure serve a common US objective of coercing Iran to accept American conditions.

The two sides are still fighting over control of the Strait of Hormuz, with retaliatory attacks on shipping and military installations. On Friday and Saturday the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and Iran’s regular army separately claimed several new cases of vessels hitting naval mines or being struck by projectiles after attempting routes they called unauthorised. The United Kingdom Maritime Trade Operations said in its Friday weekly report that it recorded eight incidents in and around the strait, mostly on the southern route near Oman. UKMTO also recorded 139 outbound and 169 inbound transits during the week, approximately 65 percent below pre-conflict levels.

Hadian said Iranian decision-makers will not tolerate the current situation indefinitely. “The authorities will either go after their warships, their vessels, or their military bases,” he said. He added that the stronger the blockade becomes, including maritime pressure and disruptions to overland borders and air travel, the more probable war becomes. He said Trump’s sidelining of Vance will not radically alter the situation, because Washington believes economic pressure can force Tehran to make concessions. “The US would have done this with or without Vance, and I believe it will continue to do this,” he said.

JD Vance Iran talks · Strait of Hormuz · UKMTO shipping report · US Iran war · Donald Trump · Mohsen Rezaei · United Kingdom international affairs and world news