Skip to content
World events. A considered read.
7 min read

Russia wants NATO back at 1997 lines, curbing Britain’s nuclear role

Before a Trump-Putin-Xi meeting in Shenzhen, Moscow has revived demands that NATO return to its 1997 positions and that Britain and France stop extending nuclear protection to other Europeans.

Newsroom
A hand points toward Eastern Europe on a large map spread across a wooden table, with two photographs of surfaced submarines in the foreground.

Russia has revived a demand that NATO return to the military positions it held in 1997, before the alliance expanded into Central and Eastern Europe, including Poland and the Baltic states of Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia. The New York Times reported that the position was set out in an unsigned document dated 10 November and circulated by Russian officials during the latest negotiations. A copy was obtained by the newspaper.

The document calls on NATO members to halt further expansion and to rule out military activity across Eastern Europe, the South Caucasus and Central Asia. It goes beyond Moscow’s December 2021 demands, which sought an end to NATO nuclear-sharing, by also requiring France and Britain to rule out using their nuclear weapons to defend other European countries. French President Emmanuel Macron has previously signalled a willingness to extend France’s nuclear protection to European allies. The proposal also demands an end to Western military assistance to Ukraine and says Russia would accept Ukrainian membership of the European Union only if Kyiv did not take part in the bloc’s common defence policy.

The Times reported that the position was raised during last week’s talks in Abu Dhabi. Several people present said Russian representatives argued that the Cold War division of Europe into separate spheres had helped reduce the risk of direct confrontation. The newspaper said it remained unclear whether Moscow would keep these demands. Two people familiar with the discussions described the document as Russia’s opening position and said President Vladimir Putin might show flexibility on NATO-related points. An American official said envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner reminded the Russian delegation that much had changed since December 2021 and urged Moscow to focus on the future.

The demands come as the White House prepares for a trilateral summit on Thursday 19 November between President Donald Trump, Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum, which China is hosting in Shenzhen. The White House confirmed the meeting after weeks of negotiations. It would be the first gathering of its kind involving the leaders of all three countries. Trump is also expected to meet Xi separately; no one-on-one meeting with Putin is planned.

U.S. officials said the three-way talks would focus on preventing a nuclear arms race and on the war with Iran, a close ally of both Russia and China. The White House has insisted that the war in Ukraine will not be on the agenda. Reuters reported that Beijing opposed Moscow’s request to include Ukraine, and Washington argued the summit was not the right forum, particularly after direct Russia-Ukraine talks resumed last week under American mediation. Two people familiar with preparations told Reuters that an agreement in principle to hold the meeting had been reached, but that the format and agenda were not final.

The last U.S.-Russia nuclear arms control treaty, New START, expired in February 2026. It had limited each side’s deployed strategic nuclear warheads to 1,550. Trump rejected Putin’s proposal to extend those limits temporarily, insisting any new deal should also include China. China is estimated to have more than 600 nuclear warheads, a figure the Pentagon expects could reach 1,000 by 2030, while the United States and Russia each have more than 5,000 warheads in their overall inventories. Beijing has long resisted limits, citing that gap, and has not confirmed that arms-control talks will be central in Shenzhen. American officials acknowledge that no nuclear agreement is expected. One U.S. official told the Associated Press that the administration hopes the gathering will start a broader conversation on arms control.

Officials in Kyiv and European capitals remain concerned that Putin could still use the meeting to advance wider aims. The Wall Street Journal reported that he had pushed for a trilateral summit in the hope of a Ukraine settlement without Kyiv or European allies at the table, and that he raised the idea in an 9 October call with Trump. After that call, Trump announced an easing of sanctions on Russian diesel exports. Analysts say the chances of a meaningful Ukraine deal at the summit are extremely low, and it is unclear whether China would discuss the war. Xi is believed to see the meeting as a way to present Beijing as a central player, while favouring tightly planned encounters unlike Trump’s improvisational style.

Some analysts have compared the plan to the February 1945 Yalta Conference, where Franklin D. Roosevelt, Joseph Stalin and Winston Churchill discussed the postwar order. For many in Eastern Europe, Yalta remains a symbol of later Soviet dominance. According to the Journal, Putin views Shenzhen as a chance to promote something resembling a second Yalta and to present Russia alongside the United States and China. Russian nationalist Alexander Dugin told Radio Sputnik: "It shows who is important in the world: We are, China and the West." Analysts largely dismiss the idea that Trump and Xi would agree a formal division of spheres of influence. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov rejected the Yalta comparison, saying understandings in Shenzhen could not be imposed on other countries and that the international order should rest on mutual benefit and respect.

Reuters reported that officials in Ukraine and Japan had expressed concern. President Volodymyr Zelensky warned last month against another Yalta in which major powers negotiated influence over smaller countries. Trump has repeatedly signalled a wish to reduce American involvement in European security and to limit Washington’s commitments to NATO. Kurt Tong, a former senior State Department official now at the Asia Group, said the president would seek to use the visit to reassert his leadership. The summit also follows major Republican losses in the U.S. midterm elections, with Democrats gaining control of Congress.

Washington’s latest effort seeks two parallel agreements: one to end the fighting and another on Europe’s wider security, including NATO’s military presence. Last week, Kyiv and Moscow held their first direct talks in nine months in Abu Dhabi and agreed in principle on a large prisoner exchange, without a broader breakthrough. On Thursday, Witkoff and Kushner met Putin at the Kremlin, then met Zelensky in Dublin on the sidelines of a gathering of European leaders. European governments regard discussion of the continent’s security architecture with Moscow as a significant concession. After the Kremlin meeting, the envoys said Russia had agreed to let European representatives join the next round with Kyiv.

Putin still demands that Ukraine surrender large areas in the east and south and seeks what would amount to a withdrawal of NATO forces from parts of Eastern Europe. Speaking in Dublin, Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk warned that accepting Moscow’s terms would directly threaten Poland’s security and were unacceptable to Europe, especially countries that joined NATO after the Cold War. Kushner wrote on X: "In our private discussions, both sides understand that practical compromises will be necessary to end this war."

Zelensky questioned the envoys’ willingness to negotiate NATO and Europe’s security architecture with Russia, arguing that ending the fighting should come before redesigning the security of an entire continent. He disclosed that American negotiators had raised the possibility of Ukraine withdrawing from parts of the eastern Donbas still under Kyiv’s control in exchange for NATO membership, which Moscow has called a red line and which Trump’s team had previously indicated was not an option. "The Americans raised a question: 'What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?'" Zelensky said. He reiterated that Kyiv was unwilling to surrender territory, but did not reject the hypothetical outright. He said that if Ukraine were offered a comprehensive settlement with credible security guarantees, the right to keep a strong and adequately equipped military, and financing for reconstruction, he would put the proposal to a national referendum.

NATO 1997 positions · Britain nuclear weapons · Trump Putin Xi summit · Shenzhen APEC · Ukraine war talks · New START treaty · United Kingdom international affairs and world news