Keir Starmer’s former Brexit minister has said Vladimir Putin’s war in Ukraine and Donald Trump’s attitude to Nato make a closer relationship between the UK and the European Union a win-win.
In his first major newspaper interview since leaving office, Nick Thomas-Symonds backed Andy Burnham’s calls to rebuild ties with the EU. He said the prime minister was “absolutely right” to explore options to change the Brexit settlement. Speaking to The Independent, the ex-cabinet minister, who led “reset” talks with Brussels until Mr Burnham became prime minister in July, said: “It's about safety, prosperity and security for the UK and the EU together.” He added: “We can do better, so much better. And we can do better in a way that isn't about one side losing, one side winning.”
Mr Burnham is preparing to meet EU leaders in Brussels on Friday 20 November to sign the latest Brexit reset deal. The agreement is expected to be a “launch pad” for looking at more radical options to reverse Brexit, including possibly rejoining the EU after the next election. Those options are expected in the prime minister’s 10-year plan ahead of the Christmas recess. Friday’s deal is expected to align the UK with EU food and drink rules so damaging border checks can be removed, and to cover students through Erasmus and a youth mobility scheme.
A decade on from the Brexit vote, Mr Thomas-Symonds said the international picture is very different. He said the war in Ukraine and a shift within Nato mean links with European partners on defence are ever more critical. Asked whether this is a “win-win” moment with the EU, he said: “I really do think that.” He said closer relations are welcomed inside the EU not “because of a sense of nostalgia” but because, at this moment in history, “being close to other partners in the world that share your values is a very, very important and mutually beneficial thing”. From his travels around the UK, he said there is no doubt the current arrangement is not satisfactory.
Last week the EU’s former chief Brexit negotiator, ex-French prime minister Michel Barnier, also hoped greater ties could be a “win-win” and described Brexit as “lose-lose”. Mr Thomas-Symonds, a key ally of Sir Keir Starmer through his premiership, suggested the Starmer government would have started a similar process after next week’s EU-UK summit. The meeting is meant to bring the UK closer to the bloc and could cover young people’s mobility, food and drink checks and other issues in Labour’s “reset”. He said that if he and the previous prime minister had completed this phase, there would then have been a debate about the next Labour manifesto and the red lines on which the party was elected in 2024. Because of how events unfolded, that debate has started around the same time as the summit. Labour’s red lines still rule out a return to the customs union, the single market or freedom of movement.
Mr Thomas-Symonds said he was “optimistic” about UK cooperation with the EU’s new Made in Europe industrial policy. Ministers fear the UK could be hit by the plan, intended in part to protect European industry from cheap, high-quality Chinese goods such as electric vehicles. He said many EU firms in supply chains with British firms do not want those chains disrupted, and that “made in Europe” should mean the EU plus trusted partners, of which he thinks the UK is one. He expects hard work on it over the next few weeks.
He said the UK should open talks with the EU now on options for a close relationship, to avoid a rerun of 2016’s “fantasy debate”. He said the debate can no longer rest on supposition or assumption and must set out realistically what each option would mean in practice, including the trade-offs. He said officials on both sides of the Channel will look at the options. Asked if the talks could help avoid rows over £350 million on the side of a bus, he said “yes”, while also letting the UK examine rejoining the EU or joining the single market or customs union “realistically”.
He said he was “surprised” by the extent of some Brexit red tape. He was given an export health certificate that was 22 pages long and required 56 wet stamps. Last week The Independent reported that the cost of trading with the EU had topped £7bn in just four years. A parliamentary committee has warned the reset will have a cost, with the UK having to accept a new EU regulation every 12 hours on average. It found the food and drink deal is likely to require the UK to adopt “at least 780 pieces of EU law” each year.
