Peter Kuznick, professor of history and director of the Nuclear Studies Institute at American University, has told Mehr News Agency that the war on Iran carries an unacceptable risk of nuclear escalation. He said that even a slight chance of the United States or Israel using a nuclear weapon against Iran must be prevented, and that the risk is now more than slight.
The warning comes as the arrival of the USS Theodore Roosevelt raises the number of US aircraft carriers in West Asia to three. Tehran has said it would not necessarily wait for Washington to launch another attack before responding. President Donald Trump has told advisers he may hold off on further strikes if Iran and Yemen’s Ansarullah do not engage in new provocations. Kuznick said reports of discussions in Trump’s circle about nuclear weapons, pressure from Israel, and hawkish advice from Stephen Miller, Pete Hegseth, Sebastian Gorka, Elbridge Colby, Brad Cooper and Marco Rubio make such an outcome possible.
He said Israeli intelligence alleges Iranian nuclear activity at “PickAxe” Mountain under 300 feet of granite, a depth neither the United States nor Israel can penetrate with conventional weapons. He estimates that Israel has between 90 and 250 nuclear weapons and will not give them up while it believes its security is threatened. Israel, he said, is the only state outside the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty in the region formerly called the Middle East, while Western powers led by the United States have shielded it from greater scrutiny. Iran, a treaty party that had allowed IAEA monitoring until the June bombing of its nuclear facilities, has faced sanctions, bombings and assassinations for uranium enrichment that the treaty permits.
On the longer pattern behind the confrontation, Kuznick said Washington has treated Southwest Asia as vital to its security and to control of oil. He recalled that in 1944 Franklin Roosevelt told British ambassador Lord Halifax that Saudi oil would belong to the United States, Iranian oil to the British, and Iraqi and Kuwaiti oil to both. He described the 1953 CIA overthrow of Mohammad Mossadeq, after Iran nationalised an oil industry whose proceeds Mossadeq argued belonged to Iranians rather than British oil companies. Mossadeq had been Time’s man of the year in 1951, and the US ambassador said he had the support of 95 to 98 percent of Iranians. The Shah was installed, and US oil companies soon held 40 percent of the Iranian market. Kuznick said the British and later the Americans used a divide-and-conquer strategy to keep control.
He argued that the war could devastate the non-proliferation regime. Membership was supposed to offer some security against attack by a nuclear power, but he said that has failed before, citing US attacks and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine after Kyiv gave up Russian-built nuclear weapons. He said 73 percent of South Koreans want their own nuclear weapons, Polish President Nawrocki has said Poland needs them, and Ukraine’s President Zelensky has said Ukraine should join NATO or receive its own. He added that Ayatollah Khamenei had declared a fatwa against a bomb, the CIA assessed in 2003 that Iran had abandoned a weapons programme, and the IAEA had reported full compliance under the JCPOA, yet Iran was bombed by one acknowledged and one unacknowledged nuclear-armed state.
Kuznick has drafted a letter asking Pope Leo XIV to call an emergency summit, at minimum of Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping and Trump. He said the letter, published on the Nuclear Insanity Substack, has been endorsed by close to 250 influential people. With Ivana Nikolic Hughes, he has called in Al Jazeera for those three leaders to eliminate nuclear weapons in three stages over 12 years, revisiting what Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev nearly agreed at Reykjavik 40 years ago. He said the threshold for nuclear winter is now known to be much lower than scientists thought in the 1980s. Former US director of national intelligence Tulsi Gabbard warned 18 months ago that the world was closer to nuclear annihilation than ever, and Kuznick said the danger has since become much worse.
He also warned that attacks on civilian infrastructure could make the region uninhabitable. By one estimate he cited, desalination supplies 99 percent of Qatar’s drinking water, 90 percent for Bahrain and Kuwait, 86 percent for Oman, 70 percent for Saudi Arabia and 70 to 80 percent for Israel. He pointed to Iran’s Bushehr nuclear power plant and Israel’s Dimona complex as vulnerable targets. Recalling Gabbard’s 10 June 2025 message from Hiroshima, he said the bomb that destroyed the city was primitive beside today’s weapons, yet it flattened an area of almost two miles in every direction, killed tens of thousands, and left radiation still killing people more than 81 years later.